Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Will Marshall's avatar

Really effective review Eric! While I disagree that the film’s sentimental moments are an unnecessary indulgence of Garland’s, I think that its sense of eclecticism does work to the detriment of the film overall.

You identified the post modern sensibility to construct a film around the preconceived image of others very powerfully in the contrast between Boyle’s iconoclasm and Garland’s nostalgia-fuelled characters of the ‘Jimmy gang’. This film does feel conflicted as to whether it wants to be a cultural touchstone mirroring earlier entries or something which purposefully subverts them altogether and that to me is its greatest pitfall.

Expand full comment

No posts